Undead argument: the truth-functionality objection to fuzzy theories of vagueness
نویسنده
چکیده
From Fine and Kamp in the 70’s—through Osherson and Smith in the 80’s, Williamson, Kamp and Partee in the 90’s and Keefe in the 00’s—up to Sauerland in the present decade, the objection continues to be run that fuzzy logic based theories of vagueness are incompatible with ordinary usage of compound propositions in the presence of borderline cases. These arguments against fuzzy theories have been rebutted several times but evidently not put to rest. I attempt to do so in this paper.
منابع مشابه
Vagueness, Logic and Use: Some Experimental Results
Although the use of experimental data is a somewhat new methodology for philosophers, research on vagueness is poised to make excellent gains from the approach. This is because any theory that purports to explain the vagueness of natural language can benefit from data about how ordinary speakers use vague words. Nonetheless, we must carefully consider the kind of evidence that we're interested ...
متن کاملA NEW APPROACH FOR PARAMETER ESTIMATION IN FUZZY LOGISTIC REGRESSION
Logistic regression analysis is used to model categorical dependent variable. It is usually used in social sciences and clinical research. Human thoughts and disease diagnosis in clinical research contain vagueness. This situation leads researchers to combine fuzzy set and statistical theories. Fuzzy logistic regression analysis is one of the outcomes of this combination and it is used in situa...
متن کاملVagueness Is Rational under Uncertainty
We seek to show that some properties of vague scalar adjectives are consequences of rational communication. Theories of vagueness are usually directed at a cluster of traditional philosophical desiderata: how vagueness fits into a theory of truth (or metaphysics), the sorites, and related issues. These are important, and we will have more to say about some of them, but we also seek to refocus t...
متن کاملFuzzy Logic and Theories of Vagueness
Fuzzy Logic has been successfully applied to all kinds of scenarios, where degrees of membership and truth can be systematically discerned. However it is highly contentious whether this fact renders Fuzzy Logic an ideal tool for modelling reasoning with vague concepts and propositions. There is a lively and prolific debate in analytic philosophy about so-called theories of vagueness. Interestin...
متن کاملVagueness and Extensionality
We introduce a property of set to represent vagueness without using truth value. It has gotten less attention in fuzzy set theory. We introduce it by analyzing a well-known philosophical argument by Gearth Evans. To interpret ‘a is a vague object’ as ‘the Axiom of Extensionality is violated for a’ allows us to represent a vague object in Evans’s sense, even within classical logic, and of course...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- Synthese
دوره 194 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2017